�g��Q��D�F�v��v�T

�g��Q��D�F�v��v�T
�w�L�R�x�W��D�ƪ��]��w

��ؤ�

�@�@�g��Q�A�j�Ӻ~�ڬF�v��ƪ��A��F�ȧg�D�Ϊv��¦�A�ܤ��S�b��а�Ѱ�r�޹C��F�C�Y�Ϧb��٤w�g�ڤJ�ۥѥ��D�D�q��a��L��x�W�A��ȩ�l�D��D��L�{�A�Ʀܩ�i�}�d�T��D��U�A�^�H��i�ݨ�䴧��h��v�T�F�ӥB�A�F�誺�g��Q�w�v��P��誺��D�D�q��b��`�۵��X�A��Ϯ`�x�W��D�F�v��@�j��~�C��x�W�A�H�ξ�Ӿ��а�Ѱꪺ��D�ƨӻ��A�X��g��Q��w��n��D�C

�@�@�g��Q�D�H�ҿפT��`��b�A��w�Ѧa�g�ˮv��a��F��֤ߦb��u��v�r�A�@�譱�A�n�D�ѧ��˪@�ج��g�A��s§��L��A��W�N�A�H�d�T�g��v�¤δL�Y�F�b�t�@�譱�A�h��W��R��p�l�A�n�j��L�p�A�y��U�b�U��̦ܥ��A�H��t�g��ҡC��A�p�K��X�G�u��a�K�K�O�H�㦳��[��ڦ�t��v�k��׬��`�p��¦�A�q�ӯ�b�H�a�x�p�Ͳ��A�~��g�٥��쪺��|��A�l�׫O��{�ꪺ�O�q�M�ǲΪ��ĩʡC�K�K��a�@�e�j�աy��z�O�߰ꤧ��A�j�է@��|��Ū��۱`��Ǫ��n�ʡA�`�O�D�`�{��a��ΩM��Ī��C�o�N��_�ǥ]�A�R�|�D�a��q��E�b��׾��a�ɭn��G�y�ǧg�ڤ��l��§�A�C�Ұ��O�A��i��]�z�A�Y��a��s��۱`�W�d�A��|��ǬO��i�ܩ��]��@�^�C�v�b�o�رq�a��D�q�X�j��F�v��ƤU�A�a�譺��|�Q�٬��x�O�@�I�]��ȱo��Y��C��~�ڤ��䶫��x�W�A�򥻤W��O�s�ۧ��㪺�g��Q�C��F�~�ڲ��ұa�Ӫ��U�ߺD�~�A�L�h��F��F�d�T�F�v��ǥѱШ|�C�鵥��q��H�Ǽ��A��O�@�j�D�]�CMarc Ferro�o�{�A��v�D�q�ɥN��x�W�ǵ��ۤp�ǱШ|�}�l�A�a�z�M��v�K�D�@��W�ߪ��ǰݡA�ӬO�Q��@�Ǳ¹D�w�зǪ��u��C�]�A�Ч��j�q�X�{�H��Ы�Q��¦��`�q�G�ơA��O�P�j�ƷR�걡�ޮ��]��G�^�C�ƹ�W�A��F��ɪ��v�D�q�F�v�A��g��Q��O��ǵ۷R��Ш|��F�v��|�ơA��s�H�Q�v��ƪ��@��n��C�]�]��A�ɦܤ��A�g��Q��M�b��g�N��a��z�A�æ��_��C

�@�@�b��嫰��ɥNĬ��ԩ��M�f�ԹϮv�{��ǻ��v�T�U�A��@��N��D�F�v�P�u��M�F�v�Ρu�ɥ��F�v�e�W��ɦV�A�ýT�H��̲ױN�]�h�ƪ̪��ɤO�ӧΦ��u��D��v�C�H�۬��ꪺ�W�ߦb�ڬw�Ȱ_�F�@�ѷW�áA��D�D�q��@��ȳv��Y�A�ûP�ۥѥD�q��X�y�A�~�}�l�٥h��L�t��C�M�ӡA�k��F�v�Ǫ̦��J��(Alexis de Tocqueville)�b��W�ۡm��ꪺ��D�ĤG��n�K��o�Xĵ�y�A�{��D�F�v�U��@�D�q�M�ӤH�D�q��i��ɭP��l�ƪ��|�M��v��F��A�ӳo�O��L�F��A��D��ӭȱo��~��V�G�u��D��a�H��K�K��۵M�ɦV�A�O�⤽�@�ưȥ浹��Q�q��ߤ@��B�ä[��N��h�B�z�C�o�ӥN��N�O��a�C�K�K��D��a�H��M��|��먺�Ǵx��j�v��H�A��󤤥��F�v��L�̫o�O�l�׾��@��C�K�K��v�ƱN�O�۵M��F��Ͷա]��T�^�C�v��L�h�󬰷��ݤ��v�ƪ��s�κA�F��A��F��ɭP��|��h��O�A�[�Ӥ[��ٷ|�s�F��]�ܱo�n�z�L�઺�ɦV��~�A��Y��O�A�o�ؤ�q�j�j��a��N�i�H��N�a�I�ǹ��a�X�G��󨪻r�r�a�@�L��ƥB��ήz�p��ӤH�C��ަ��J��N�ۥѥD�q��ܳo�عL�פ��v��F�餧�Z��A�M�[��x�W�A�^�H��S��N�Ѩ쥲��D�D�q�P�ۥѥD�q��A�Ϧӥ��ѧg��Q�P��v�ɦV��ĦӤ��۪��C

�@�@�x�W��ۥѥ��D�ơA��M�b�L�{�W�O�ǥѥ��O�ҫP��A��O��ʮ�W�٬O�ѤW�ӤU��i��ﭲ�C��D��Y�O�@�إͬ��˦��M�ߺD��A�Y�ϥx�W�{�b�w�g��ܬF��A��i�קK�uŧ�F�غإ]�A�g��Q�b��¨�׶ǲΡF�Ӧb�o�ܰʤ��A�x�W�D��S��ܹL�h��a��v��A�Ϧӧ�ַN�h�[�j��v��A�Ʀܤ��묹�a��۪v�]��|�^�A�H�W�[�ﭲ��t�פδT�סC�Y�ص{�פW�ӻ��A�x�W�Ұl�D��ﭲ�A��D�q��Ҥj�L��D�D�q�C�s��ѡA�D�b�g��Q�y��F�x�W�H��ݱϥ@�t�D�M�U��F��ߺA�A�ө��F�w�w��D�D�q�̭��n��ݦb��H��ۤv�޲z�F�v�ưȪ��۫H�P��O�C�o�]��O��O�u�D�q��m�@�p��F��Ѱ�A�|��X�{��U��F��D�i��]�C�ب몺�O�A��x�W�H��ƾ��ۥH�g��Q�ӥ[�֦ۥѥ��D��e�i�ɡA�o�O��[�֦ۥѥ��D��¡C

�@�@�g��Q�ɭP��v�T�A�ëD�ȫ]��󤤥��v�ƪ��譱�C�ѩ�L�h��v�D�q�ɥN��Ϊv��󮧩M��A�g��l��̤w�g��@�s�ȹȫݭ��ʫĵ��A��Ѥ��@�ưȡA�ߺD�ۨ̾a��˨ӸѨM�g�D�Ҧ��Ʊ��A�ƾ��ۧQ��v�¨Ӳ��\��@�СC�ҥH�b�x�W�A�X�{��M��@�۫H�v�¡A�o��۫H�M�~��{�H�A�o��P�L�h�~�ڪ��|�W�L�h�j�ҥ禳�W��A��L�צp��A�o�˪��Ҥ]��y�F�\�h��o��{�X�L�Ҥ��H��F�ҥH�b�x�W�A�`�|�X�{�@�ѭ��ϥ��D��h��n��A�b�@�譱�H�~�֬��ѡA�ܩڦ~��w��򪺵��x�v��F�æb�t�@�譱�~��۫H�ѤH�P��M��@��礧��A�C��o�ͤѨa�a�ܮɡA��ѥm�{�W��̻ݰO�o�U�@�o�v�H�¤ѤU�C�ҥH�b�x�W�A�@�N��D��D��F�v�H��A��ݱq�L�̨��W��^�L�h�g��v�C�ҥH�b�x�W�A�L�רƱ��j�p�һP��F�̦��A��ܬG��i�H�M�n�D��x�t�d�o��b�@�_�A�p�P�u�b�a�W��x��⪺�ĵ��@��L�k�W�ߡC�ҥH�b�x�W�A�Z�O�\��F�v��ݭѭn�j�k�x�X��ˡA��޳̲ר��²��J�@�O�A�٬O�o�B�Φۤv��F�v��z�M�F�v��O�ѨM�C�ҥH�b�x�W�A�H��D�v��I�n��M�T��]�A�H�H�o��ۤv��Ϫ��ڹB�@�L�ର�O�B�z��ߡA��M�n�D�ۥѥ��D��@��۪v�ۥD�A��s�b��|�벼��Ѫ��D�F�v�A�òߺD�N�ﭲ�z�Q�P�F�v�d��Ʊ��Ө�L�H��W�C�ҥH�b�x�W�A�󤵤�ۥѥ��D�|��W�y�D��ڡA�N�w��N��D�D�q�P��D�q��W��n��A��a�۹�h�ƨM�w��H�M��L�h�ɥN��q�h�C�i�H��A�g��Q�w�g�]��F��D��ת��A��F�ۥѷN�Ӫ��B�ΡA��x�W�F�v��Ƴy��۷��{�ת��ᦱ�C

�@�@�`��A��D��|��v�ɦV�P�~�ڶǲΪ��u�g��Q�v��X�A�̲ױN�ܦ��i��ɭP�쥻��F�O�@�ӤH�ۥѦӤ��_��Ȫ��v�F��A�o�H��N�I�ǭӤH�ۥѪ��p�o�͡C�]�]��A��v�O��P��a��۪v�A�̰��g��Q�P�d�T�ۥѥD�q�D�O��e��n�ȡC��D�D�q��f��̨}�Ĥ��٬O��D�D�q�A��p��J��ĭz��G�u��Q��۪v�ߺD��H�̡A��X�v�z�L�̪��H�F�]��۫H�B��A��H��A�i�H��X�@�ӦۥѡB�n��B�ʹ��F��]��^�C�v

��n��m�F�ȦۥѤơB��D�ƻP�ϰ�M��n��ڶ��Q�׷|�פ嶰

��@�@��A�p�G�m��j�N��Q�v�סn�A�T��ѧ��G�x�_�A1996�A146��C�q��E��y�X��m�v�O��ӥv��ۧǡn�C

��G�@Marc Ferro�A��W��v��Ķ�G�m�sしい�@�ɥv――��@��で�l��に歴�vをどう�yっているか�n�A�s��סG�F�ʡA1985�A357-361��C

��T�@Alexis de Tocqueville, Democracy in America, translated by G. Lawrence, Chicago: Encyclopaedia Britannica, 4th printing 1993, pp.363-365.

��|�@�x�W�F��2006�~�T��N�m��https://��אּ�x��C��s�D�Ghttps://archive.udn.com/2002/9/19/NEWS/FOCUSNEWS/POLITICS/997580.shtml�C

��@Alexis de Tocqueville, op. cit., p.377.

�@